Monday, December 31, 2012

India in the Times of Transition


The sociocultural values, fundamental beliefs, priorities of a nation undergo transformation with time.  The process of transformation is in general a slow and continuous process that provides ample time to the nation to adapt to the changing environment. However, in the post-globalization globe, emerging nations have moved fast in economic front. Along with economy, the fundamental value systems, cultural ethos of these nations have started morphing.  India is a good case in hand.
Though India is largely an agrarian economy, the Hindu rate of growth is history for India.  For last several years India is growing at a yearly rate of more than 5%. Unlike countries that have transitioned from agrarian economy to manufacturing economy and then to service economy; Indian has skipped the middle phase to focus on service sector directly from agriculture. Indian banking and finance sector is considered as among the best of the worlds, Indian IT companies have established themselves comfortably in the competitive world. Indian talent is being appreciated around the globe.
At the same time India is witnessing a lot of challenges in its path of growth and development. To decode the contemporary context of India one has to focus on the major dimensions of changes that India is confronting with.

Democracy and Politics
Indian democracy is no more a playground of a single political party. Today, we witness regional satraps having their say in national scene.  Politics is now a politics of coalition, sometime addressing the contradictory demands of two different coalition partners.  A sizable chunk of Indian electorate has moved out from the traditional way of choosing representatives on the basis of caste and political party. They are now concerned over the issues of development and progress of their region. Large voter turnout in all recent elections is a result of interest of common electorate in the issues related to their constituency. Gone those days when high voter turn-out was essentially being seen as symptom of high anti-incumbency voting. Electorate is turning to polling booth both to support good governance and to throw a non-performing government out of power. 

Confusion and Corruption
With fast changing policies, dynamic economic environment confusion and corruption seem to have increased manifold. 2G spectrum allocations, coal block allocation; numerous mining scams at state government level appear to be mix confusion and corruption at policy level and implementation level. Indian administration and policy making is now dealing with multimillion dollar multinational companies which never had such a deep presence in the countries boundaries.  Politicians have also floated their own business enterprises or have become advocates or consultants of companies who lobby of their own profit and growth. Crony capitalism has made inroads into Indian life. 

Public Institutions
Role of public institutions have become more critical for functioning of this country. Fortunately, in India institutions like CAG, Election Commission have managed to come clean in the environment of confusion and corruption. Their independent stand and impartial decisions have put the corrupt elements of administration on an alert. At the same time, public institutions are increasingly being challenged by central and state governments who had till now exerted their unquestioned authority and power of common man.
Indian judiciary still lacks the strength to enforce regulatory majors, ensure smooth functioning of the law. Judiciary reform is being talked for decades, but nothing has happened on the ground. Despite the shortfalls, Supreme Court of India has managed to carry the hope of billions of Indians.

Indian Media
Indian media now has become either a corporate house that seeks profit or a tool in the hands of political parties that ensure selective publication of news items. Profit motive has undoubtedly come in the way of delivery of transparent and true news. Selective deformation of news creates confusion in the minds of readers/viewers. Lack of ethical journalism, investigational reports and excessive sensationalism is increasingly becoming a norm. 

Indian Youth
Indian youth has started challenging the system, asking questions and seeking answers. In recent past India has witnessed huge anti-graft movements. Lack of security for women has again made Indian youth and students to come out of their home, to protest on the street seeking accountability from the political class. Social media and internet has helped youth to connect with larger sections and voice their opinion. It is being said that some of the protests/demonstrations were organized using social media as an effective tool of communication.
Till now the decision making class had been using the resources for their own need and greed.  They had enjoyed security from police force, uninterrupted supply of electricity and water, unrestricted access to places of importance. Now Indian youth has started asking for the same, they have started asking the basis of such discrimination and disparity in availability of common resources.
As India moves further in the path of development, Indians will ask their politicians, administration tougher questions. They no more could be silenced and ignored. Public institutions, judiciary, media will be subjected to even more demanding times. Evolution of this emerging nation will be full of excitements, conflicts and progress.

Sunday, November 25, 2012

Book Review: Agnostic Khushwant: There Is No God!


With Fifteen chapters "Agnostic Khuswant- There is no god" tries to highlight the dogmatism and irrationality associated with religions across the world. The authors are of the view that religious scriptures must be seen as books of literature and not as rule books as many things in such books are questionable and lack logical reasoning. The authors dare to challenge rituals, religious processes and Godmen. 

In the last two chapters the book is critical on the Dalai Lama and Swami Vivekananda. Some of the quotes of Vivekananda provided in the book makes a typical Hindu rethink about the high position provided to him. For example, the book says around 100 years ago Swamiji had predicted that Europe will crumble in another 50 years. 


The authors have provided some description about the source and basic tenets of all religions. However, what distracts a reader is disproportional discussion on Shikh religion. Again it is difficult to find out how much of the quotes are result of selective absorption, selective retention and selective distortion. Authors at many places have provided quotes leaving it to the reader to interpret. At some places the book lacks natural flow and structure, some concepts/information are repetitive in nature. 


The book will be a great read (except a few chapters) if you have been blindly believing religion and rituals. It will make you think. If you believe every creation needs to have a creator and God is that creator, the book will simulate your intellect to ask who has created God. 


Not a great read if you have already done some research on religion and its origin; if have evaluated logically the rituals and their significance.

Friday, November 16, 2012

Is India Growing?


Most of us are happy that India is among the top most countries in terms of GDP growth. Some of us sincerely believe that higher GDP growth with translate into better quality of life for the larger section of the society. Can we accept GDP growth as the only parameter to measure growth of a country? Shouldn't overall development be our prime concern? Does higher GDP growth essentially translate into better quality of life?
To be very frank, most of the popular media, politicians and contemporary discussions have conditioned our mind in such a way that we believe India will become superpower soon. It is crucial to understand the fundamental factors that make a county developed.
No doubt, ancient India used to be an advanced civilization comparable, in some cases better than the western civilization. However, with industrial revolutions, dynamics of nations evolved in a rapid pace. The most crucial revolutions could be clubbed into three broad categories:

  • IR A: 1750 to 1830 (Steam engine, railroads etc.)
  • IR B: 1870 to 1900 (electricity, internal combustion engine, running water, indoor toilets, communications, entertainment, chemicals, petroleum)
  • IR C: 1960 onward (computers, the web, mobile phones)
Let us decode how the major inventions have impacted quality of life in the most parts of the world. IR A and B have made transportation easier and most of the works that were performed manually by human beings are now performed by machines. As a result the quality of lives of people have improved, they live their life in a more meaningful and dignified way. All these industrial revolution started in western world.
Now countries that have fully extracted the value of industrial revolution have been able to provide better life to its inhabitants. We call them developed countries.
Coming back to India, forget about IR A and IR B, we as a nation are still struggling to prevent hunger death our citizens. Though many well qualified Indian believe that we are a truly emerging superpower as we are well ahead many countries in IR C, i.e., computers, the web, mobile phones etc.
It doesn't require any complicated analysis to understand when people of India are yet deprived of the basic benefits of IR A, when many of us still carry water and other heavy things on our back; how can we claim to reach IR C. And can we shut our eyes to poor education system, poor health care, and lack of drinking water, electricity even in SEZs and growing cities?
We need to differentiate the distinction between moving on the path of developing nation and making a selected few developed. What India has managed to provide better quality of life to a selected few, purchasing power of the rest of the population remains low despite high inflation.
Many of us still don’t understand and unfortunately not exposed to poor performance of this so called emerging superpower in social parameters. Forget about China, India is lagging behind Bangladesh in most of the social parameters. Its irony that the way our media highlights GDP, IIP figures; don’t highlight social parameters. 

Hope sooner India will prioritize its activities and would start focusing in extending the benefits of Industrial Revolution to larger section. Making the rich section richer will not make us a super power, rather we will get entangled in complicated issues like the Naxalite problem. 

When Bangladesh which has poorer infrastructure, GDP growth rate, private sector can perform better than us in many social and health parameters; we need to admit our collective failure in providing better life to our people. And the example of Bangladesh is sufficient to prove that better quality of life doesn't necessarily depend upon high economic growth.